Categories: Uncategorized

The Need for Answers

Here’s a flickr photo titled The Need for Answers that’s been garnering a fair bit of attention lately:

The problem with this image is that it makes the classic mistake of mistaking science for religion or philosophy — essentially a sort of equally-bad inverse of the Creationist mindset. Science is for answering the “how” questions, while religion and philosophy are for tackling the “why”. The photo oversimplifies the nature of faith in that typical hip not-quite-done-rebelling-against-my-parents way that’s popular these days. The same people who often don’t quite buy into the notion of a creator will often talk about karma as if it were Newton’s Third Law for Morals.The silliness goes both ways, as well, if the study that reports that atheists are the least-trusted group in the US is accurate.

I personally believe that science and religion are not mutually incompatible, and as Wil Wheaton put in the comments for the photo, there’s a big grey area right down the middle that’s missing. Perhaps that’s why Einstein quipped that “science without religion is blind, and religion without science is lame,” and why he also observed: “There are only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle” (Reverend Victoria Weinstein does a much better job of covering this in a recent sermon).

Food for thought. Feel free to comment…

Joey deVilla

View Comments

  • To be fair, the concept of faith has been so denigrated by the people who speak loudest for it (and insist so thoroughly on it), that it shouldn't surprise us when so many others take a dim view of it.

Recent Posts

Notes for the kakistocracy, 2025-03-05: DOGE is the real fraud, David Brooks on the Zelenskyy ambush, disrespecting veterans, defending institutions, and “Elbows up!”

Maybe the real fraud was the fraud that DOGE made up along the way https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=71hKowGIpHM…

1 day ago

Tampa Bay deal of the day: STRIPPER POLE

Some notes about the screen capture above, which I took from Facebook Marketplace... Tampa Bay…

3 days ago

Sunday picdump for March 2, 2025

Another Sunday, another “picdump!” Here are 200+ memes, pictures, and cartoons floating around the internet…

4 days ago

Notes for the Kakistocracy, 2025-03-01: Facebook and content moderation, shut the f**k up, do not obey in advance, and no one is coming to save us

Kakis-what? Kakistocracy, meaning a government run by the worst, least qualified, or most unscrupulous citizens.…

5 days ago

Please DO NOT invite Andrew and Tristan Tate to Tampa

Even uber-Republican Florida Governor Ron DeSantis says they’re not welcome, but the Tampa Bay Young…

6 days ago

Be wary of the company you keep

For context, see this article: U.S. votes against a U.N. resolution urging Russia's withdrawal from…

1 week ago