Yours Truly!
About a month before the last Canadian Federal Election, Enter Stage Right, a site popular with some of my conservative compatriots in the Canadian blogosphere, ran an article titled Victoria Day and the Life and Death of Traditional Canada. It inspired one of my more popular entries in this blog, the “My Canada Includes Accordion Guy” article, which got a lot of enthusiastic response in the comments and only one hand-wringing “maybe the problem is YOU!” semi-rebuttal from a knee-jerk conservative in another blog’s comments.
The
reason that a lot of us are loath to support the Conservative Party is that
we suspect that they a lot of them don’t like us. It wasn’t that long
ago that it was once the Reform Party.
This was the party of Bob Ringma, who suggested that gays
and “ethnics” could be fired or “moved to the back of the
shop,” if the employer thought that would help business.
We left the Philippines in 1975, not to suckle on the Canadian welfare teat, but because President Ferdinand Marcos
declared martial law and the democratic system was replaced by a
military dictatorship. We left for the same reasons many longer-time
Canadians’ ancestors did: to seek out a better life.
We came
here with skills: Dad’s an obstetrician-gynecologist, Mom’s a
cardiologist and both trained both in the Philippines and in the U.S..
My sister and I were educated here, and she ended up following the
family trade and became a doctor of community medicine and works at the
Peel Region Board of Health.
I’m the “black sheep” of the family
— I have only a bachelor’s degree and went into computer programming.
Even so, my work history speaks for itself: I’ve worked for Mackerel
Interactive Multimedia, one of Canada’s highly-regarded interactive multimedia companies, then one of Canada’s most ambitious dot-coms and finally Tucows, one of Canada’s best-known internet companies.
Simply put: if we took benefits from Canada, we paid them back in spades.
A
favourite bogeyman of Conservative supporters is that immigrants are
often the thin edge of the wedge, sponsoring the rest of the clan for
immigration as soon as they get their citizenship papers. In 31 years
here, the only one in my family who’s ever sponsored someone to
immigrate here is me. I’m sponsoring my wife, who last worked at
Harvard’s Berkman Center for Internet and Society.
We
understand that a wide-open-door policy would be disastrous, but at the
same time, we don’t subscribe to the belief that many Conservative
supporters seem to — that all people who don’t look like descendants
of the Family Compact or Chateau Clique are subhumans out to bleed the country dry.
There’s
lots of common ground shared by immigrants of my ilk and some of
Conservative supporters. Most of us were lucky enough to have parents
who bypassed a lot of North American baby boomer culture and its
extended adolescence, and thus didn’t have to “raise our parents while
raising ourselves” (I suspect that this is the source of a the
wooly-headedness amongst people some of the people who vote for the NDP
by reflex). We come from cultures where hard work is valued, capitalism
isn’t a dirty word and ambition is a virtue. And we do love a Tim Horton’s
double-chocolate donut. It may not be the land of our birth, but it’s
the land we chose to call home, just like your forebears did. Like
them, we hope to leave the place a little better than we found it.
If
the Conservative Party wants my vote, they’ll have to convince me that
they’re not the same as the party from which they grew. They’ll have to
convince me that they’ve moved beyond the “Every since my family came
to Canada, we’ve had nothing but crap from the immigrants” mindset.
I know some Conservative campaigners and supporters who aren’t cut from
the Bob Ringma mold, and with whom I’ve shared a pint of Upper Canada
Dark, so I know that someday, I may be convinced.
Tomorrow is not that day.
3 replies on “Tomorrow is Not That Day”
Speaking out of my own experience, the “it’s too easy to get into Canada” speech is not quite true either. Hailing from a country not really (yet) considered third world (Germany) I have to jump through quite some hoops myself (oh, how I look forward for the waiting once all the papers are in place).
Looking at my income tax returns filed over the last five years here in Canada can say that I paid easily more than $170K in income tax, I am also privilged to pay into EI which I could not ever claim (right now) if need be.
Canada is a lot more “hospital” to immigrate to (without sponsorship) I think than the US is, but that doesn’t make it easy, and I am pretty certain that people coming from “third world countries” most likely have it a lot worse than I could ever have it.
As someone who was born in Canada, I can honestly say that I do not consider myself any more Canadian than any immigrant. To me it does not matter where you come from, or how you got here – it only matters that you are here now.
My Canada includes diversity and equality. I will not give my vote to any party that does not believe that whole heartedly as well.
I’m not sure Bob Ringma is the correct by which to judge Canadian conservatism. His comments are certainly ridiculous, but he does not speak for all conservatives any more than the Marxist-Leninist party speaks for all progressives.
I can’t say I’ve heard the immigration sponsorship argument from Conservative supporters very often — in my experience, at least, the reverse is true. Socialist associations can be very intolerant, especially if you are a visible minority person who doesn’t happen to subscribe to their ideals (and is vocal about it).
My family (both Japanese and European halves) arrived here over a hundred years ago, and while we have all had to endure our share of bigotry, I consider it a poor reflection on the individual alone. Tarring a group of people because of the intolerance of a few just doesn’t seem that logical. Asking us to prove we’re not bigots is a bit rich, really. I can prove I’m not Bob Ringma. I can’t prove that no one in the party — or for that matter, the Liberal or NDP parties — thinks like he does.
Rather than suspecting conservatives don’t like you, why not try to engage us, as you have in the past. I think you will find that while we disagree with you on a wide range of policy issues, that is no obstacle to treating you in a civilised, friendly manner befitting a fellow citizen and contributor.
Chris Taylor
(P.S. Sorry, I couldn’t figure out how to register a user ID via the commenting script on your site)