Categories
It Happened to Me Toronto (a.k.a. Accordion City)

The Balanced Meal

Regular readers of this blog will know that last night, a fundraiser for the MP in my riding, Sam Bulte, was held at the Drake Hotel, a boutique hotel that’s become one of the city’s more popular after-work and weekend hangouts. The fundraiser, billed as a celebration of artists and creators in honour of a friend to the creative community, was in fact more of a political strokefest between the Canadian Recording Industry Association and a politician who supported a bill that was very restrictive of user’s rights.

Ren Bucholz of the Electronic Frontier Foundation called together a counter-gathering at the same hotel, where those who opposed Big Content’s vision and Sam Bulte’s pandering could meet, get to know each other and talk. No recitations of manifestoes, no angry scribblings of blog entries or letters to the editors, but just folks with a common interest meeting over food and drink in one of my favourite cafes in town.


I had to get a photo of the sign in the lobby. It’s pretty poor (I didn’t want to call attention to myself while doing it), but as you can see, the event is a fundraiser, contrary to Ms. Bulte’s vehement denials:

A good number of people arrived early and the cafe was filled to capacity soon thereafter. We each took turns introducing ourselves and found that we were all sorts of different people, from techies like myself, Ian Goldberg and Kat Hanna (whom you may remember from their adventures with Dell Computer and click-wrap licencing), to musicians such as Neil Leyton and Mike Farrell of The Pariahs (a guy who predates me at Crazy Go Nuts University), photographers, writers, students and people who just classified themselves as “ordinary citizens”.

I have to commend The Drake for letting us gather there. Ren had communicated with them in advance to book some space in the Corner Cafe, and they could’ve easily said “no” for fear of offending the fundraiser folks, who’d be a far greater source of revenue than we. I also have to commend the Corner Cafe for making their own marshmallows for their hot chocolate — I’m going to be a return customer on that touch alone.


I got a chance to talk with Ren for a little bit, and he told me about the EFF’s presence in Canada. He’s the only EFF guy in this country, having started at the position about nine months ago. We talked about all sorts of things, from the blog-powered hubbub over Bulte to Copynight, a gathering that takes place on the fourth Tuesday of every month where people talk about restoring balance to copyright law. Ian and Kat also mentioned this and informed me that the next local gathering takes place next Tuesday night at 7 at The Madison, a place that I normally associate with drunken college reunions and think of as a safe training ground for bar pick-ups for people freshly out of school. It’s nice to see “The Maddy” broadening its client base!


It was also good to see Neil Leyton, whom I hadn’t had a chance to

catch up with since 2002, when he and I were musicians in Lindi’s live

band, with him on guitar and backup vocals and me on you-know-what.

Neil told me about how he used to stick a line on the copyright notices

for his albums where it would say something like “Hey, if you listened

to this album from start to finish non-stop with no bathroom breaks,

you are are entitled to copy and distribute it freely!” He then

discovered Creative Commons and found that their licenses said roughly

the same thing in a more official way, and now his record label, Fading

Ways Music, is a big user and supporter of Creative Commons licenses.


A funny note — the Drake had a contingent of security guards, sharply dressed in black suits with black turtlenecks, communicating with each other on walkie-talkie cellphones. One of them glared at me when I took the photo of the sign announcing the location of the fundraiser, but a hotel staffer who knew me told him “Oh, don’t worry, that’s the Accordion Guy. He’s cool.”

Later, as I left the cafe to use the bathroom, two of them blocked the door that led to the hallway leading to the fundraiser room.

“You using the bathroom?” one of them asked.

“Yup,” I replied.

“One from the cafe to use the bathroom,” said the other one into his walkie-talkie as I opened the bathroom door, shaking my head and smiling in amused disbelief.

Categories
In the News It Happened to Me

My Biggest Source of "Hits" Today…

…is the Macleans piece, Wrath of the Bloggers, which features quotes from Cory Doctorow, Michael Geist and yours truly. Right now, 15% of this weblog’s incoming traffic is coming from there.

Categories
In the News It Happened to Me Toronto (a.k.a. Accordion City)

Even More Questions from the All-Candidates Meeting

That’s right, even more from my notes on last week’s all-candidates meeting. In case you missed them, here are my earlier entries on that meeting:


Question Seven: The Gun Crime Question

What are you going to do about gun crime?

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • This is a question that I hear repeatedly, and there are no simple fixes for this problem
  •    

  • Nobody needs a gun
  •    

  • Many of the guns are coming from south of the border [remember, American readers, to us, “south of the border” means “America”]
  •    

  • The border is unpatrolled in many places and there isn’t enough staff to cover all of it
  •    

  • Gun crimes need to be treated with mandatory jail time
  •    

  • Also need to work on communities — “poverty by postal code”

Sam Bulte   

  • Key gun crime laws died on the table because of the vote of non-confidence [which led to this election]
  •    

  • We need more police — both local and RCMP
  •    

  • We need to work with youth as well — there has to be some prevention — can’t just be “law and order”
  •    

  • We should ban guns

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party   

  • We can’t resort to an “iron-fisted approach”
  •    

  • Society has to live up to its responsibilities, and individuals have to live up to their responsibilities
  •    

  • We have to balance going on the offensive with respecting people’s rights
  •    

  • “Arc of poverty” — one-quarter of the people in the city live below the poverty line

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party   

  • This is possibly the most important issue
  •    

  • There’s a “big business” running the streets — the drug trade
  •    

  • The drug trade and guns are intertwined
  •    

  • Tougher laws and mandatory sentences for gun crimes

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • mumble mumble mumble Legalization of marijuana will end organized crime mumble mumble

Rob Rischinsky, Green Party   

  • We already have strong gun laws
  •    

  • The problem is with illegally-obtained guns
  •    

  • Let people who want to have gun collections keep them, but make it so the guns in those collections are non-functional
  •    

  • Gun sport enthusiasts can also keep their guns, but store them at the place where they are used [e.g. their shooting range]
  •    

  • We believe in restorative justice

Question 8: What will you do for seniors?

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party   

  • Many of the programs in place for seniors were put there by the Liberals

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party   

  • Here in Canada, we have the resources to provide for all
  •    

  • Unfortunately, providing for everyone’s needs is not a principle we follow

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party   

  • We will give patient care gurantees
  •    

  • We want to expand the definiton of “caregiver” so that more people who take care of the elderly qualify for benefits

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • We would like to commit $1 billion a year over the next four years to programs that would give more seniors the ability to stay in their own homes rather than go to old folks’ homes

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • mumble mumble Revenues from marijuana mumble mumble mumble

Rob Rischinsky, Green Party   

  • Some reasons that older people need help: pollution and our lifestyle
  •    

  • Wait till the boomers hit the system
  •    

  • We want to provide universal access to senior care

Question 9: The Environment

[My notes on the question are bunged up, but it’s a question about the environment.]


Rob Rischinsky, Green Party
   

  • We can have both economic prosperity and environmental health
  •    

  • Look at Sweden: since 1990, their GDP has gone up 54% while pollution has gone down 25%
  •    

  • Kyoto [the accord] is the first step
  •    

  • Note that there was no mention of the environment in the televised debates

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • The NDP has made sure that money was given to the TTC and the energy retrofit program
  •    

  • We stand for:       
             

    • Clean air
    • Clean water
    • Making polluters pay
    • National energy retrofit program
    •        

  • [The way we’ve implemented] Kyoto is a national shame

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • mumble mumble hemp mumble mumble forests mumble mumble fuel

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party   

  • The Kyoto Accord — led by the Liberal party
  •    

  • Funded Great Lakes cleanups, targeted Toronto
  •    

  • We have invested $5.1 billion in the environment

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party   

  • The type of economy we live in will always clash with the environment
  •    

  • As long as the profit motive exists, that clash will always exist

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party   

  • Kyoto is a disgrace
  •    

  • We’ve missed every deadline
  •    

  • Now we have to buy credits
  •    

  • We proposed tax credits for people who take public transit
  •    

  • We will invest in renewable fuels
Categories
In the News It Happened to Me Toronto (a.k.a. Accordion City)

More Questions from the All-Candidates Meeting

Sorry it took so long, but here’s more from the All-Candidates Meeting. If you missed the other installments:


Question 3: The “Psychotropic Drugs” Question

“There’s no right answer to this question,” said the guy who was next in line, “but I’m just as interested in the way you answer it.” The question was about psychotropic medication — there’s a loophole in the law where people can prescribe psychotropic drugs to children. What would you do to fix that loophole?

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party

  • The public health agency should be able to help
  •    

  • Will establish a mental health commission
  •    

  • Will also hold dialogues cross-country

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party   

  • I’m not in favour of commissions
  •    

  • I helped introduce Steven Fletcher, who’s likely to be Minsiter of Health — I’d bring the issue to him

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • That’s crazy!
  •    

  • The Ministry of Health should be able to close this loophole

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • (A lot of indignant mumbling) full disclosure commission
  •    

  • My notes from this point read: “mumble mumble mumble”

Rob Rischinsky, Green Party   

  • I’d establish a commission to reduce the use of psychotropic drugs
  •    

  • We have to recognize that there are alternative treatments

Question 4: Toronto the ATM

Toronto sends a lot of money to Ottawa — in fact, $13 billion more goes out of the city than into it. Would you support the return of one-quarter of that money? It could go to transit, education, social services and the environment

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party   

  • There’s a full GST rebate for municipalities
  •    

  • Money from the gas tax goes to cities
  •    

  • We’ve given Toronto a bonus for the TTC’s ridership, providing $350 million in partnership with the city and provincial governments

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • We need equalization
  •    

  • The Liberals implemented the gas tax because of pressure from the NDP
  •    

  • The NDP is the champion of cities

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • Legalizing marijuana will lead to tax revenues which will provide the city with money

Rob Rishchynski, Greeen Party   

  • We propose a “Green tax shift” — where personal incomes taxes are reduced to 0 while taxes on pollution and waste are increased
  •    

  • We would transfer tax authority to the local level

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party   

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party

  • We’ll meet with Mayor Miller and the local Business Improvement Areas
  •    

  • We understand the issues and will introduce initiatives

Question 5: One from the Kids

At this point, they opened the floor to the local kids who were in attendance. The first one: How would you decrease child poverty in Canada?

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • Poverty has many causes:       
             

    • Lack of affordable housing
    •        

    • Low minimum wage
    •        

    • Lack of childcare
    •        

  •    

  • We also need program to assist new Canadians to give them assistance in settling in; credentials

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • mumble mumble social assistance mumble mumble revenues from legal marijuana mumble mumble

Rob Rishchynski, Greeen Party

  • There are ways to solve child poverty:       
             

    • Pay people a living wage
    •        

    • Provide benefits and child tax credits for people with children
    •        

    • Provide daycare
    •       

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party

  • We’ve done a lot — there’s the Liberal child tax benefit that put money directly in the hands of families
  •    

  • I agree with Peggy Nash — combating poverty requires a holistic approach

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party   

  • It’s telling that a young person asked this question — young people are always most concerned about the future
  •    

  • Canada has vast resources, skills and technology
  •    

  • We can provide for everyone — it’s just that the allocation of wealth isn’t even
  •    

  • We have to stop paying the rich
  •   

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party

  • Poverty is reflective of the lack of posterity
  •    

  • Prosperity leads to generosity
  •    

  • We would fight poverty with       
             

    • Education
    •        

    • Small business opportunities
    •        

    • Apprenticeship programs
    •        

       

Question 6: Another from the Kids

How is the government going to invest in our future?

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party 

  • Education is the key to prosperity
  •    

  • Access Canada
  •    

  • 50/50 program provides up to $3000 of tuition
  •    

  • We need money for measures to help students graduate

Rob Rishchynski, Greeen Party   

  • We will work with the provinces to decrease tuition
  •    

  • Paying off debts can cripple someone just out of school — loan paybacks should be scaled to match the income from a first job
  •    

  • We believe that there should be apprenticeship programs and a mentorship network to help people just out of school build the skills they need

Lorne Gershuny   

  • The aim of government should be to eliminate tuition fees
  •    

  • Anyone with the motivation and ability should be able to get an education

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party   

  • We need to encourage people to get into skilled trades
  •    

  • More programs for apprentices
  •    

  • More small business incentives

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party   

  • We need to reverse cuts to post-secondary education
  •    

  • Need to provide stable long-term funding
  •    

  • Need to establish a program of life-long learning
  •    

  • Need to create a national apprenticeship program

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party   

  • Pass
Categories
Geek In the News It Happened to Me

Bulte Round-up

Boss Ross Gets in on the “Remixing Sam” Act

I’m not the only one into the commentary-on-Bulte-by-Photoshop game. My boss, Ross, has taken a crack at it and he’s done a pretty nice job:

Ross won’t mind if you copy this graphic and stick it on your own site.

Ross also notes that he took advantage of advance voting and will gladly tell anyone who asks that Sam did not get his vote.


In This Week’s Macleans: Bulte in the Blogs!

Michael Geist has informed me that along with Cory Doctorow, we’ve been quoted in this week’s issue of Macleans. We were all interviewed by Colin Campbell last week, and our comments appear in a sidebar article titled Bulte in the Blogs: A Dust-Up Over Campaigns and Copyright. Here’s a scan of the bit where your ‘umble blogger gets mentioned:

He sent me a scan of the article [825K PDF], which I have enclosed for your viewing. The scan’s a bit smudged, but I’m planning to buy a half-dozen copies for my portfolio and will see if I can get a cleaner scan posted here.


Doctorow’s Guest Editorial at the Star

Speaking of Cory, if you haven’t read his Toronto Star guest editorial piece on Sam Bulte — Trademark Political Shenanigans — do so now!

My favourite bit is where he talks about DRM — “Digital Rights Management” or “Digital Restrictions Management”, depending on if you’re one of Sam’s God-fearing content corporation buddies or one of those no-good “pro-user zealots” whom Sam condemns. He’s come up a great way of explaining the ridiculousness of region-encoded DVDs (which is why your North American DVDs won’t play in other parts of the world and vice versa):

These are the technological restrictions put on the media that you buy,

such as games, CDs and DVDs, that seek to control how you use works

after you buy them. These DRMs indiscriminately restrict the

enjoyment of your lawful property, allowing rights holders to control

your private use of media in ways not considered under copyright law.

For example, Adobe’s eBook technology blocks your ability to copy and

paste a quotation, even where copyright law would allow it, e.g. in the

course of criticism or in academic research.

DRM technology on

DVDs prevents you from watching discs bought overseas in a Canadian DVD

player, despite the fact that copyright doesn’t give creators the right

to control where their creations are viewed after they’ve been sold.

That’s why you don’t need to leave your Canadian editions of your

favourite books at home when you go on holidays in foreign countries.

Categories
In the News It Happened to Me Toronto (a.k.a. Accordion City)

All-Candidates Meeting: First Two Questions

Here are my notes from the first two questions asked at Wednesday’s all-candidates meeting. Just in case you missed it, I also have an entry containing my notes on the opening statements.


Question 1: Island Airport

[As a resident of the area] we are in the flight path leading to the Toronto Island airport. We expect that if it goes into the use planned by the Port Authority, we can expect 5 hours of flights and noise…[starts soapboxing]

[Someone in the audience yells “Ask the question!”]

[Taken slightly aback] What are your plans to close the Island airport and shut down the Port Authority?

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party:

  • Would prefer that it was a big park
  •    

  • Liberals failed to deal with the issue
  •    

  • Now the Port Authority is suing Toronto

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party:   

  • I’m with the GTA caucus, and we were instrumental in killing the Island bridge [part of the plan for the airport]
  •    

  • The federal government was not involved in this issue
  •    

  • The Port Authority serves a purpose [wag in audience says: “Yeah, patronage!”
  •    

  • Remain to be convince that a Port Authority hand-over would be a good thing

Lorne Gershuny, Marxist-Leninist Party:   

  • We would consult with people in the neighbourhood for their opinions

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party:   

  • Just as Adscam was a “gift” to Quebec, the Port Authority fiasco was a “gift” to Toronto
  •    

  • The bridge got cancelled, yet we have to pay $32 million [that’s what the Port Authority is suing the city for]

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party:   

  • [unintelligible] don’t know issue [unintelligible] but will listen

Rob Rishchynski, Green Party:

  • Alternatives exist: service Pearson [Toronto International Airport] with subway link

Question 2: Proportional Representation

The “first past the post” system of elections here leaves many small groups under-represented or locked out. What are your opinions on proportional representation?

Peggy Nash, New Democratic Party:   

  • The current system skews democracy and emphasizes regionalism
  •    

  • It is antiquated
  •    

  • The NDP favours a “mixed proportional representation” system [as opposed to a completely proportional one] as recommended by the Canadian Bar Association

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party:

  • That’s one of our promises

Lorner, Marxist-Leninist   

  • Proportional representation would make things marginally better
  •    

  • The party system is outdated, from a time when white males dominated
  •    

  • Today we are dominated by parties

Jurij Klufas, Conservative Party

  • Proportional representation: interesting
  •    

  • Concerned that “the process is lengthy”
  •    

  • Conservatives have proposed some intermin solutions:       
                 

    • Independent director of public prosecution
    •            

    • Federal accountability act
    •        

       

Terry Parker, Marijuana Party:   

  • Will have to discuss this one with the party

Rob Rishchynski, Green Party:   

  • We support it
  •    

  • We’re the only party that you can vote for knowing that we’ll do it

Sam Bulte, Liberal Party [rebutting]:

  • It was part of our February 2004 Democratic Reform Action Plan!
  •    

  • We had cross-country roundtables
  •    

  • The provinces are looking into it
  •    

  • There’s academic research into the issue
  •    

  • We’re talking to people about it
  •    

  • Proportional representation [in and of itself] is not always the answer — you need political will
Categories
Accordion, Instrument of the Gods It Happened to Me

Photos from Wednesday’s All-Candidates Meeting

In case you were wondering: yes, I actually did bring the accordion to Wednesday’s all-candidates meeting (you know, the one with the now-infamous Bulte video). Its purpose was strictly visual: I was simply making my presence known.

Paul Nielsen pointed me out to this photo album of shots taken from that meeting, which includes the pic on the left of yours truly with the trusty “street” accordion at my feet, diligently taking notes.